This might have been a good interview had there been a Pacific panel capable of deconstructing Clydesdale's report. Much as I admire Barbara Dreaver's journalistic professionalism and the witty and incisive Oscar Kightley, so much more might have been achieved had a panel of Pacific business experts or Pacific economists been invited to provide an informed analysis of Clydesdale's report. Simply dismissing the report as unacademic is foolish and naive.